Across denominations, churches are short of the people who lead them in song. Writing for Christianity Today, Kelsey Kramer McGinnis reports on a study by SBC Worship which found that 70 percent of worship leaders nearing retirement age have not identified a successor, and which projects that the Southern Baptist Convention alone — the largest Protestant denomination in the United States — will need 20,000 new worship leaders by 2040.
Most church musicians arrive the way Anna Dunsbergen did. She enrolled at the University of Northern Iowa planning to become a teacher, joined a college ministry and its affiliated church, and accepted an invitation to join a worship internship. After three years she felt called to full-time ministry. Now 25, she is in her second year as worship leader at The Chapel in West Lafayette, Indiana, a church plant of the Salt Network that has grown to a 1,000-person congregation in three years. "I still love education, but I don't know if I'll ever have a teaching job," she told CT. "I definitely see myself doing this for a long time."
That relational, on-the-job route is the norm, and it is why researchers are asking whether recruitment and preparation need rethinking. Will Bishop, chair of the worship studies department at William Carey University and one of the lead researchers on the study, said he gets multiple calls every week from churches looking for singers, pianists and guitar players. "We want to sound the alarm and put the word out," he said. "So much has changed in the past 50 years. People in the pews have gotten busier, adult and children's choirs have disappeared. The ways we used to identify the next generation of church musicians aren't there anymore." There is no standard credential for the role: the survey found that 68 percent of worship leaders hold no degree in music, worship or ministry. Master's programmes at institutions such as The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, Dallas Theological Seminary and Liberty University require coursework in theology and biblical studies, but they are designed for students who already have musical training and ministry experience.
Bishop wants strong musical and theological education at Christian colleges and universities, but he is convinced that training must begin in local churches — and some congregations are acting on that. At Candeo Church, the church affiliated with Dunsbergen's college ministry, director of music ministry Dalton Shaffer built an internship for college students and then a postgraduate residency that employs worship leaders with the intention of sending them to another church after two years. Residents take seminary courses but are not required to complete a formal ministry degree. A six-week "worship intensive" covers setlist planning, theology of worship, speaking and on-stage leadership, and is open to anyone in the church, including high school students. "Nobody wanted to train a worship leader and then send them somewhere else," Shaffer recalled of early scepticism. "Sending costs something." He is willing to put inexperienced musicians on stage, knowing the sound engineer can mute them in the mix. "You're never going to get there if you don't have a place to fail," he said.
The trade-offs are real. The average tenure of a worship leader at a church is less than three years, and narrowly focused pipelines can limit a leader's options on leaving ministry. Elevation, the North Carolina megachurch known for its worship music, launched a degree-granting college last year with tracks including worship, production and ministry. Casey Corum, a producer and instructor at Biola University, told CT that such programmes cannot provide the rigour of a traditional music degree, with its theory, history and ensemble requirements, and that an in-house practicum educates students within one particular spiritual community. "Church is a great place to get discipleship and leadership training, but it's not always a great place to improve musicianship," he said.
For congregations that govern themselves, the question is practical rather than administrative. A denomination can plan a pipeline from the centre; a free church usually trains whoever is in the room. The examples in the report point the same way — Shaffer's residents, Dunsbergen's interns, the cellist who is also a John Deere engineer — and Bishop's suggestion that larger congregations become training centres for rural and smaller ones. "One of the ways these big, thriving churches can serve rural and smaller congregations is by becoming training centers," he said. The next generation of church musicians, on this account, is most likely to be found and formed locally, and sending them out is part of the cost of the work.
Source: Christianity Today — christianitytoday.com