What Calvin Taught About the Lord’s Supper — and the Pull Toward Rome

Pastor George Robertson reads Calvin’s teaching on the Lord’s Supper, and asks why the table draws some believers toward Rome.

· 3 min read
A gold cross on the lid of a communion vessel
Image: The Gospel Coalition

George Robertson begins with a pattern he keeps meeting in ministry: parishioners converting to Roman Catholicism, and, when he asks why, returning again and again to the Lord’s Table. They speak of the encouragement of identifying the bread and wine with Jesus’s body and blood. One put it plainly: “My faith just feels more real if I’m literally bringing Jesus into my body on a daily basis.”

He remembers an ordination service years ago, and the seminary professor who preached a solid sermon on the ministry only to appear on television the next day explaining that he had resigned his post and gone to Rome. “I needed more realism than my tradition provided,” the man said. He had taken to walking to a local Catholic parish at lunchtime to receive the Eucharist, finding a literal union with Christ’s body and blood more satisfying than the “mystery of union with Christ” his own church taught. Robertson has heard the same theme from others who have left for Rome, for Orthodoxy, or for Anglo-Catholicism: a longing for a more transformational, sensory reality than the Reformed view of the supper seemed to offer.

Is the criticism fair? Robertson grants that it has force. Reformed Christians, he admits — himself included — sometimes speak only of what the communion elements are not, and in doing so can drive believers to look elsewhere for a more “real” experience. We can “get caught up in debating the exact nature of the bread and wine and forget to ask the more pressing question: How should this meal change me today?”

His answer comes from John Calvin’s Short Treatise on the Lord’s Supper, which he reads as setting out three ways the meal fuels spiritual growth. First, the supper assures believers of their inheritance in Christ — not as a psychological boost, but by a real union with him, experienced through faithful partaking of the covenant meal. Calvin, commenting on Ephesians, writes: “Paul says that we are members of his [Christ’s] flesh and of his bones. Do we wonder then, that in the Lord’s Supper he holds out his body to be enjoyed by us, and to nourish us unto eternal life?”

Second, the supper confirms and increases faith. It is a public, dramatic statement that God has atoned for sin, given because he knows “our faith is slight and feeble” and that, “unless it be propped up on all sides and sustained by every means, it trembles, wavers, totters, and at last gives way.” At the table, Calvin says, the ascended Christ by his Spirit lifts our hearts to heaven and steadies what is weak. Third, the supper motivates and enables obedient living: “There cannot be a spur which can pierce us more to the quick than when He makes us, so to speak, see with the eye, touch with the hand, and distinctly perceive the inestimable blessing of feeding on His own substance.”

Calvin’s conviction shaped how he ordered worship. In his arrangement the whole service was one long expression of gratitude, concluding at the table — and he would not let worshippers keep that gratitude to themselves, because it is a gift meant to be shared and a motivation towards practical “faith and charity” to others.

For traditions that celebrate the supper occasionally rather than weekly, Robertson’s point is a corrective worth hearing: the table is not merely a memorial of something finished, but a means by which the risen Christ feeds and grows his people now. He closes simply: “the next time you come to the Lord’s table, come expectantly. The living, risen Christ will use communion as fuel for your spiritual growth.”

Source: The Gospel Coalition — “How the Lord’s Supper Fuels Spiritual Growth” by George Robertson, 6 November 2026.