Few arguments in the modern church have worn people out like the worship wars. Traditionalists complain that contemporary songs say “I” too often, that there is more “me” than “Thee” in them, that God is no longer the subject of the verbs — or, in the parody that has stuck, that the songs sound like “Jesus is my boyfriend.”
Writing for Christianity Today, the Episcopal priest and theologian Porter C. Taylor opens by conceding that the complaints contain some merit. Some contemporary lyrics are genuinely curious — he cites John Mark McMillan’s infamous “sloppy wet kiss” — and some songs focus more on the worshipper than on the one being worshipped. But Taylor argues that counting pronouns cannot tell us whether a song’s words are faithful, and that the worship wars may have been fighting the wrong battle all along.
The same critique, he notes, can be turned on the hymnals the traditionalists revere. Many hymns also emphasise the wrong elements and focus too much on the worshipper; some carry questionable theology; and, in his words, “our hymnals contain some real stinkers.” The late William H. Petersen had to rewrite portions of the Advent favourite “Lo! He Comes with Clouds Descending” to remove antisemitism. The solution, Taylor writes, is not simply more hymnals.
The better question is not whether a song makes accurate statements about God but what it enables the gathered church to say and do before God. A song may proclaim God’s holiness, confess sin, cry out for mercy, or teach a congregation to delight in God’s presence. Taylor calls these “different theological actions,” and says Christian worship needs the full grammar of the church’s response: proclamation and petition, confession and adoration, lament and thanksgiving, the corporate “we” and the personal “I.”
To recover that grammar he returns to the Psalter, Israel’s prayer book and the early church’s songbook — the Hallelujah Psalms (146–150), the Songs of Ascent (120–134), the Egyptian Hallel (113–118). The Psalms are full of the first-person singular: “The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear?” (27:1); “Create in me a clean heart, O God” (51:10); “I love the Lord because he has heard my voice” (116:1). How, Taylor asks, can the church’s corporate prayer book so often speak in “I”? His answer is Augustine’s: when the church prays the Psalms, it is the whole Christ who prays — Head and body united in a single voice. “He prays for us, as our Priest,” Augustine wrote; “He prays in us, as our Head; He is prayed to by us, as our God.” Commenting on Psalm 131, Augustine insists the words “ought not to be received as the voice of one man singing, but of all who are in Christ’s Body… as it were one man speaks: and he is one who also is many.” The “I,” in other words, is singular grammatically but communal ecclesiologically.
That reframing produces a sharper diagnosis. The problem with contemporary praise music, Taylor suggests, is not that it says “I” too often; it may be that its “I” is not yet capacious enough. He names the pastoral cost: a grieving parishioner made to sing repeatedly about overflowing joy, a believer in spiritual desolation required to proclaim God’s immediate presence, a repentant worshipper with no opportunity to confess. Those songs are not false, he says — but a repertoire that cannot hold the church’s actual life is too narrow for the church’s actual life.
His conclusion is not a verdict for one side. Traditional and contemporary forms are both necessary and complementary, and both are “certainly worthy of critique.” For congregations that gather without a fixed liturgy, though, the argument carries particular weight: where there is no prayer book, the song list does much of the work a prayer book does elsewhere, and its range is not merely a matter of taste. Taylor ends where the worship wars should have begun: “Perhaps the worship wars will end when we discover that the church’s ‘I’ was never meant to sing alone.”
Source: Christianity Today — “Why Your Favorite Worship Song’s Grammar Matters” by Porter C. Taylor, 10 November 2026.